If you’re like me, you think of two things when you hear Red Robin: bottomless fries and a soulfully sung yum, à la infamous jingle. The chain is arguably best known for its burgers, but the restaurant recently launched a slew of new chicken items, ranging from hot honey-doused wings to a light, refreshing chicken wrap with an unexpected riff on Caesar dressing. (That said, there’s also a limited-time bacon cheeseburger and a couple of fruity drinks on the menu, plus a hot honey pepperoni pizza at select locations.)

To find out which items are worth the spend, I headed to the Deptford, New Jersey location to taste them all. Read on for a food editor’s honest reviews, overall ranking and original photos to find out which new dish took the top spot.

(Note: Availability and pricing may vary by location.)